I saw it over the weekend, and liked... parts of it. The first one had a better atmosphere, and ended on more of a "silent hill-y" note, but this one stayed truer to the third game than the first one did to the first game. Adalaide Clemens killed it as Heather. She got all of her mannerisms and attitude pretty spot on. However, there were a lot of issues that came from trying to match up with the mess of the first movie's storyline, as well as just some bad writing choices.